Reviews

Best pizza in Rochester. By a long shot.
Matthew Dean via google.com - Aug 17, 2017
Best pizza in Rochester. Hands down.
Albert Parisi via google.com - Aug 15, 2017
Love it ... read more
Beckie Rivera via google.com - Aug 12, 2017
Real NY style pizza 😍 ... read more
Lola Crenshaw via google.com - Aug 12, 2017
Awesome NYC style pizza! The only thin and crispy crust place I have found in the area.
Awesome NYC style pizza! The only thin and crispy crust place I have found in the area.
Ralph Rizzo via facebook.com - Aug 12, 2017
Good pizza ... read more
Sandeep K via google.com - Jul 31, 2017
Traveling through the area and found this gem! Very friendly service and excellent pizza!
Traveling through the area and found this gem! Very friendly service and excellent pizza!
Kelly Glaze via facebook.com - Jul 30, 2017
Long line but worth the short wait for great pizza. Just wish they would deliver on the other side of the river 🙂 ... read more
Chris Spurrier via google.com - Jul 27, 2017
Best pizza in Monroe County!! Authentic New York City style pizza and awesome Sicilian(thick crust) style pizza(my favorite)!!
Dave Tobin via google.com - Jul 27, 2017
Good service and the best pizza available in the immediate area!
Meghan Hughes via google.com - Jul 27, 2017
Fast Service at lunch time. AMAZING Pizza!! Get the Meatball/Parmesan!! Sauce is so delicious!!
MaryLouise Brennan via google.com - Jul 26, 2017
Love it !
Ethel Jones via google.com - Jul 25, 2017
The pizza here is amazing! I really like the white garlic pizza and the cheese pizza! They're all g
The pizza here is amazing! I really like the white garlic pizza and the cheese pizza! They're all good!
Joshua Kemble via facebook.com - Jul 23, 2017
Visiting from California, hadn't ...
Visiting from California, hadn't had Brooklyn pizza in years. Stopped in on a Friday afternoon, had a slice of pizza and a cold beer! Oh my gosh, memories swept back into my mind of the goo dole days on the city. Best pizza I've had in years! Thank you, Jim. Service with a smile, excellent pizza pie, ice cold beer......one very happy ... read more
Blair D. via yelp.com - Jul 21, 2017
Great local pizza spot!! Friendly staff and good food.
Great local pizza spot!! Friendly staff and good food.
Krystal Meredith Lee via facebook.com - Jul 18, 2017
Best NYC style pizza. And I'd put their stuffed pizza up against anything.
Paul Monette via google.com - Jul 18, 2017
Delicious pizza. Bit high on the prices but I can handle it for the great taste. ... read more
Jarett Gardner via google.com - Jul 18, 2017
Great pizza friendly service ... read more
Elizabeth Robinson via google.com - Jul 17, 2017
Best pizza ever ... read more
Dwierl181 via google.com - Jul 17, 2017
Carb loading
We were in town for a half marathon and we were looking pizza. This place was recommended by our hotel. The pizza was amazing and very reasonably priced ... read more
Jhobbs03 via tripadvisor.com - Jul 16, 2017
Best pizza in the world ... read more
Mrbcloud via google.com - Jul 3, 2017
Best pizza in Rochester. Order a whole pie instead of a few slices to get the freshest experience. ... read more
Eric Andersen via google.com - Jul 3, 2017
Best pizza in ROC!!
John Whelehan via google.com - Jul 3, 2017
Best pizza in Rochester, not even close ... read more
Ryan Hickman via google.com - Jun 26, 2017
Nyc style pizza in rochester ... read more
Ricky Bowen via google.com - Jun 26, 2017
Probably the best Pizza I have had in WNY. Pretty similar to NYC style. Cool vibe in the restaurant itself. It's kinda expensive though, it was $12 for 4 slices. Worth it though. ... read more
Ben Dorsey via google.com - Jun 19, 2017
The pizza and atmosphere are great! Best pizza in Rochester!
Elle Michelle via google.com - Jun 19, 2017
Best pizza in western NY, closest thing to NYC/NJ pizza ... read more
Brian Doherty via google.com - Jun 10, 2017
Excellent as always 5+++* ... read more
Harry Roldan via google.com - Jun 10, 2017
Delicious pizza, good service, pretty clean shop.
Russell Kirkwood via google.com - Jun 10, 2017
Love the pizza here ... read more
Robin Matthews via google.com - Jun 10, 2017
Forget about it this is the only slice you need west of the Hudson
Forget about it this is the only slice you need west of the Hudson ... read more
Doug Rice via facebook.com - Jun 1, 2017
I thought just the pizza would ...
I thought just the pizza would be NYC style, but the service was too... I'm not sure how they find such angry/mean people to work there: I'd love to read the job description.Anyway, the pizza was good, although I wish they had a combination or one with a lot of veggies available by the slice. I would definitely ask someone else to go ... read more
Samantha O. via yelp.com - Jun 1, 2017
The pizza here is delicious! I ...
The pizza here is delicious! I especially loved the fresh homemade crust. I'm not a fan of what most of Rochester calls a NY style pizza with the thickish crust. This was a thin crust done to perfection. The sauce was great, too! If you are a pizza fan, you definitely should try this one! -- I took off one star for the dining area it ... read more
Lisa F. via yelp.com - Jun 1, 2017
Awesome lunch time carb attack for an out of towner
I felt like a local enjoying a couple slices of delcious NY style pizza here. Google led to me to this haunt while I was in ROC on a layover. A lunch of two slices and a Dr Pepper was all of seven dollars and...More ... read more
RegionalRoadie via tripadvisor.com - Jun 1, 2017
Lunch time bliss
My favorite lunch time place to go. True New York Style....mmmmm! They have thin, thick, stuffed crust whatever you like. The stuff crust is the best I ever had. If you like folding your Brooklyn pizza like I do this is the place to go.
Tim D via tripadvisor.com - May 20, 2017
Got stuck downtown waiting for ...
Got stuck downtown waiting for a ride, and decided to try this place out. The guy in front of me got a HUGE ass slice of pizza. I got excited. Then I was given a much smaller slice. Whatevs. I had a buffalo chicken slice. With. Can of soda, it came to $4.50. The pizza was think crust, deff NYC-style. Although the slice I had was smal ... read more
Andrew A. via yelp.com - May 17, 2017
Closest thing to NYC style pizza in our area. This place never disappoints. ... read more
Brian Gee via google.com - May 10, 2017
Best slices in the area no questions asked!
Bryce Mingrino via google.com - May 10, 2017
Best pizza in Rochester. ... read more
James Hiltunen via google.com - May 10, 2017
They know pizza. Top 5 in the country.
Victwa123 via google.com - May 10, 2017
Awesome I'm sitting here right now waiting for my small pepperoni and mushroom pizza and I just got finished eating a slice the workers are very nice I just love the their Pizza ... read more
Robin Matthews via google.com - May 10, 2017
One of Rochester's Best Places to get pizza from NY style & you can get a Molson XXX alrighty then
One of Rochester's Best Places to get pizza from NY style & you can get a Molson XXX alrighty then ��� ... read more
Victoria M. Lang via facebook.com - Apr 20, 2017
What can I say that has not already ...
What can I say that has not already been said - best NY style pizza in Rochester.  I have been here 50+ times, and I am never disappointed.  I would eat here every day if my metabolism would let me.  The line is out the door at lunch time, so plan accordingly.  The slice choices are extensive, and there is a flavor combination for ev ... read more
Justin G. via yelp.com - Apr 19, 2017
neat ... read more
Ken M via google.com - Apr 10, 2017
I absolutely love the pizza here! Actual New York style pizza ... read more
Megan Wasik via google.com - Apr 10, 2017
Great selection of slices for lunch! Easily my favorite pizza shop in the City.
Hotcar Nomoney via google.com - Apr 10, 2017
delicous ... read more
Colin Canfield via google.com - Apr 10, 2017
Very good New York style pizza ...
Very good New York style pizza... gets pretty busy during lunch hours. Fairly priced, quick service, great slice!
Franco P. via yelp.com - Mar 28, 2017
Pizza stop is THE go-to lunch destination in downtown Rochester. The staff is friendly, the food is literally the best in the Greater Rochester area, and the price for amazing NYC style pizza is unbeatable.
Nick Palermo via google.com - Mar 10, 2017
Easy to find, quiet atmosphere, great pizza, friendly staff! ... read more
Armeen Ghafourpour via google.com - Mar 10, 2017
Loved it, some of the best pizza is Rochester ... read more
Gregory Clausen via google.com - Mar 10, 2017
Fast and friendly, delicious ny pizza!
Amanda Kilchrist via google.com - Mar 10, 2017
Great variety of slices and at a good price. ... read more
Holden Wagstaff via google.com - Mar 10, 2017
One of my favorite pizza places ...
One of my favorite pizza places in Rochester.  They do an absolutely amazing job!  It doesn't matter if it's a single slice or whole entire pie, they and putting out some delicious product.  If you are ever in Greece, NY, you should try the Pizza Stop over off ridgeway, very similar quality.  My only gripe is about the hours, I wish ... read more
Eric H. via yelp.com - Mar 4, 2017
Amazing pizza for sure, large more that me and my son could eat. Leftovers were great the next day
Amazing pizza for sure, large more that me and my son could eat. Leftovers were great the next day as well. No skimping on the toppings either. Well worth the money 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼 ... read more
Richard Scarcelli via facebook.com - Feb 24, 2017
Always the best place to go in Rochester for a slice. So many choices, and everything is fantastic
Always the best place to go in Rochester for a slice. So many choices, and everything is fantastic. My go-to is the meatball parm slice.
Mis Ter Justin via facebook.com - Feb 19, 2017
Amazing thin crust cooked to perfection, this is some dam good pizza!
Amazing thin crust cooked to perfection, this is some dam good pizza!
Scott Mercier via facebook.com - Feb 17, 2017
Best New York style pizza around…
If you're looking for a traditional "Street pizza" style meal, then you cannot beat this spot in downtown Rochester. There are many varieties to choose from, by the slice. It's not fancy. It's just great.
Josh547 via tripadvisor.com - Feb 15, 2017
Best pizza in Rochester
Great NY style pizza sold mostly by the slice. All sorts of different topping pizzas already made, I go here every excuse I get.
NY_to_anywhere_warm via tripadvisor.com - Feb 13, 2017
Fantastic crust, delicious sauce, and a wide variety of toppings. This is a popular lunch spot, and I have also ordered pizzas to go for dinner time. The service will remind you of the character on Jerry Seinfeld's show called the soup nazi, though they're friendlier than Yev Kassem. Just don't try to place an order at the counter wh ... read more
Mark Pedersen via google.com - Feb 10, 2017
Fresh Delicious hot served food ... read more
Dexter Cosby via google.com - Feb 10, 2017
Best pizza in town! I've never had pizza from NYC but I imagine this is what it tastes like.
Best pizza in town! I've never had pizza from NYC but I imagine this is what it tastes like.
Graylynn Passineau via facebook.com - Feb 10, 2017
The best pizza in Rochester suyuyuiiiiii for real the best.
The best pizza in Rochester suyuyuiiiiii for real the best.
Suyuyui Figueroa via facebook.com - Feb 8, 2017
I've always loved to get slices here and since I don't live in the city, I had to get a couple of t
I've always loved to get slices here and since I don't live in the city, I had to get a couple of the frozen pizzas when I saw the Facebook post about it. Only tried the double pepperoni so far, it cooked great in our oven, the bottom was nice and crispy and the cheese was melted perfectly. Buffalo chicken is up next!
Stefanie Sofia via facebook.com - Feb 8, 2017
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
Google+FoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip Advisor